Government’s ‘fair deal for renters’ won’t address high rents, housing minister says

Jump to contentSign up to our newslettersSubscribeNewsSportsVoicesCultureLifestyleTravelPremiumNewsUKUK PoliticsJon StoneMonday 07 November 2022 17:31CommentsFelicity Buchan, the government’s housing ministerThe government’s plan for a “fairer deal” for private renters will not address soaring rents, the housing minister has said.Appearing at the Commons communities committee Tory MP Felicity Buchan said she believed rent rises could only be controlled by building more homes in the longer term.Last month it was reported that landlords had raised rents to record highs, with a 20 per cent rise in some areas according to listings data.Labour MP Clive Betts, who chairs the communities committee, put it to the minister that affordability was “the fundamental problem in the private rented sector” – and that the government’s renting white paper failed to address this.But the minister replied: “I think it’s very important to look at what the white paper is trying to achieve, and what it is trying to achieve is a fairer deal for tenants and for landlords. Affordability is a separate issue which is clearly very, very tied to supply. That is not the purpose of this white paper to look at housing supply as a whole. “This is about making sure that we get a good deal for tenants and landlords. The vision for the white paper is to make sure that any tenant has a decent and secure home, that they are in a position to exercise their rights, and that at the same time landlords have the ability to get possession if they need it on reasonable grounds. But this is not intended to be an overall housing strategy.”The government’s insistence that only market forces can bring down rents contrasts with the approach taken by the Scottish government, which has introduced a temporary rent cap to prevent landlords from raising rents during the cost of living crisis.Asked when an overall housing strategy looking at affordability would be published Ms Buchan said the committee should ask the communities secretary Michael Gove if he were to appear at the committee in the near future.Most European countries have some form of rent control in the private sector that regulates the rate at which landlords can raise rents – but England and Wales has been a notable exception since the market was deregulated in the 1980s.Handout photo issued by Just Stop Oil of a protester who has climbed a gantry on the M25 between junctions six and seven in Surrey, leading to the closure of the motorwayPAA grey seal with its pup, at the Donna Nook National Nature Reserve in north Lincolnshire, where they come every year in late October, November and December to give birth to their pups near the sand dunes, the wildlife spectacle attracts visitors from across the UKPADemonstrators with placards calling for a General Election march near the Houses of ParliamentAFP via Getty ImagesA peacock is seen in the early winter sunshine in the Dutch Gardens in Holland Park AFP via Getty ImagesA villager cooks roti bread at the site of the annual Camel Fair in Pushkar, in India’s desert state of RajasthanAFP via Getty ImagesA red squirrel gathers nuts in Pitlochry, ScotlandReutersEngland’s Tara-Jane Stanley scores their side’s seventh try against Brazil during the Women’s Rugby League World Cup group A match at Headingley Stadium, LeedsPAGB’s James Hall competes during the men’s parallel bars qualification at the World Gymnastics Championships in LiverpoolAFP/GettyPeople dressed in Halloween costumes paddle board along the river Avon in Christchurch, DorsetPAMembers of the public take pictures as police officers remove activists from a road during a ‘Just Stop Oil’ protest, in LondonReutersA cosplayer attends the MCM Comic Con London 2022 at the ExCel Centre in LondonReuters98-year-old D-Day Veteran Bernard Morgan, whose story is among those featured on the giant poppy wall, during the launch of The Royal British Legion 2022 Poppy Appeal, at Hay’s Galleria in central LondonPAA meerkat explores a pumpkin in the enclosure at Wild Place, Bristol, where some of the animals are having pumpkin treats as part of their environmental enrichmentPAKing Charles III welcomes Rishi Sunak during an audience at Buckingham Palace, where he invited the newly elected leader of the Conservative Party to become Prime Minister and form a new governmentPARishi Sunak celebrates with Tory MPs outside the Conservative Campaign Headquarters after becoming the new leader of the Conservative PartyReutersThe Green Man at October Plenty, Borough Market’s annual Autumn Harvest festival, in London, which returns for the first time post pandemicPASculptor Peter McKenna puts the finishing touches to a pumpkin that will form part of the ‘Planet A’ Hebden Bridge Pumpkin Trail in the West Yorkshire townPABritain’s Prime Minister Liz Truss delivers a speech outside of 10 Downing Street in central London to announce her resignationAFP/GettySalmon leap up Stainforth Force on the River Ribble in the Yorkshire Dales as they swim upriver to their spawning grounds during the annual Salmon migrationPAJust Stop Oil protesters continue their protest for a second day on the Queen Elizabeth II Bridge, which links Kent and Essex and which remains closed for traffic, after it was scaled by two climbers from the groupPAHundreds of students take part in the traditional Raisin Monday foam fight on St Salvator’s Lower College Lawn at the University of St Andrews in FifePAA protester holds a placard during a march into central London at a demonstration by the climate change protest group Extinction RebellionAFP/GettyA member of the public drags an activist who is blocking the road during a “Just Stop Oil” protest, in London, BritainREUTERSGermany’s Women’s double skulls during day one of the World Rowing Beach Sprint Finals at Saundersfoot beach, PembrokeshirePAFamily and mourners arrive at St Michael’s Church, in Creeslough, for the funeral mass of 49-year-old mother of four Martina Martin, who died following an explosion at the Applegreen service station in the village of Creeslough in Co Donegal on FridayPAMotorists in Coventry pass trees showing autumnal colourPAA woman and her dog in the the North Sea at Tynemouth Longsands beach before sunrisePAPolice officers remove a campaigner from a Just Stop Oil protest on The Mall, near Buckingham Palace, LondonPAA drummer plays during the Diwali on the Square celebration, in Trafalgar Square, LondonPATimothee Chalamet attending the UK premiere of Bones and All during the BFI London Film Festival 2022 at the Royal Festival Hall, Southbank Centre, LondonPATwo young male fallow deer lock antlers in Dublin’s Phoenix park as rutting season beginsPAThe Princess of Wales during a cocktail making competition during a visit to Trademarket, a new outdoor street-food and retail market situated in Belfast city centre, as part of the royal visit to Northern IrelandPAGreenpeace protesters interrupt Prime Minister Liz Truss as she delivers her keynote speech to the Conservative Party annual conferencePAPrime Minister Liz Truss and Britain’s Chancellor of the Exchequer Kwasi Kwarteng wearing hard hats and hi-vis jackets, visit a construction site for a medical innovation campus in BirminghamAFP/GettyBritish artist Sam Cox, aka Mr Doodle, reveals the Doodle House, a twelve-room mansion at Tenterden, in Kent, which has been covered, inside and out in the artist’s trademark monochrome, cartoonish hand-drawn doodlesPAErling Haaland celebrates after scoring Manchester City’s second goal against Manchester United at Etihad Stadium. Haaland went on to score a hattrick, his third of the season in the Premier League. City beat United 6-3.Manchester City FC/GettyProtesters hold up flags and placards at a protest in London. A variety of protest groups including Enough is Enough, Don’t Pay and Just Stop Oil all demonstrated on the dayAFP/GettyBritish Prime Minister Liz Truss, who has not been seen in days, leaves the back of Downing Street after a meeting with Office For Budget Responsibility following the release of her government’s mini-budgetGettyThe Virginia creeper foliage on the Tu Hwnt i’r Bont (Beyond the Bridge) Llanwrst, Conwy North Wales, has changed colour from green to red in at the start of Autumn. The building was built in 1480 as a residential dwelling but has been a tearoom for over 50 yearsPACriminal barristers from the Criminal Bar Association (CBA), demonstrates outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London, as part of their ongoing pay row with the GovernmentPADavid White, Garter King of Arms, poses with an envelope franked with the new cypher of King Charles III ‘CIIIR’, after it was printed in the Court Post Office at Buckingham Palace in central LondonAFP/GettyA gallery staff member poses next to a painting by Lucian Freud – Self-portrait (Fragment), 1956 – on show at a photocall for the Credit Suisse exhibition – Lucian Freud: New Perspectives at the National Gallery in LondonPALabour leader, Sir Keir Starmer is interviewed by Laura Kuenssberg in Liverpool before the start of the Labour Party annual Conference which he opened with a tribute to Queen Elizabeth II and sang the national anthemPAHandout photo issued by Buckingham Palace of the ledger stone at the King George VI Memorial Chapel, St George’s Chapel, Windsor CastlePA A climate change activist protests against UK private jets while lighting his right arm on fire during the Laver Cup tennis tournament at the O2 Arena in LondonEPAWoody Woodmansey, Lee Bennett, Kevin Armstrong, Nick Moran and Clifford Slapper attend the unveiling of a stone for David Bowie on the Music Walk of Fame at Camden, north LondonPAA flock of birds in the sky as the sun rises over Dungeness in KentPAFlowers which were laid by members of the public in tribute to Queen Elizabeth II at Hillsborough Castle in Northern Ireland are collected by the Hillsborough Gardening Team and volunteers to be replanted for those that can be saved or compostedPAThe ceremonial procession of the coffin of Queen Elizabeth II travels down the long walk as it arrives at Windsor Castle for the committal service at St George’s ChapelAFP/GettyA man stands among campers on The Mall ahead of the Queen’s funeralReutersUnder the approach laid out by the ministers, rented housing could theoretically become more affordable if there were so many landlords that they would compete with each other for tenants, lowering rents.However, when this happened in some areas during the Covid-19 pandemic, some landlords exited the market – contributing to a rise in rents. Asked what the governemnt was doing on affordability, Ms Buchan said: “Clearly we are doing a lot if you look at the broad housing policy. “So for instance we’re investing £10bn over the spending review in new housing to unlock one million homes over the course of the parliament, and we have achieved 240,000 new homes in 2019-2020, which was is one of the highest levels over the course of the last 10+ years. “We’re investing £11.5bn in the affordable homes programme. So we do have a lot going on here to increase the supply, and in particular to increase the supply for affordable housing, both for sale and for rent.’Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalismBy registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalistsAlready have an account? sign inRegistration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalismBy registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalistsAlready have an account? sign inPrivate rented sectorLandlordsHousingFelicity Buchan, the government’s housing ministerFelicity Buchan, the government’s housing ministerPlease refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in