German chancellor’s China visit sparks controversy

The timing of German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s imminent trip to China and what signals he will give to Beijing have raised questions at home, a German member of the European Parliament said Thursday.Reinhard Butikofer of the Green Party, which is part of the governing coalition, said in Taiwan that Scholz’s one-day trip is ‘probably the most controversially debated visit in the country for the last 50 years.’Scholz, who will visit Beijing on Friday, will be the first European leader to visit China since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which Germany has strongly opposed. Beijing has provided Moscow with diplomatic backing, accused the U.S. and NATO of provoking the attack and scathingly criticized punishing economic sanctions imposed on Russia. Some in the ranks of Scholz’s three-party governing coalition have questioned at least the timing of his visit. His trips to Ukraine and Russia in February also stirred controversy. Butikofer, part of a group of European lawmakers visiting Taiwan, spoke to a joint news conference from his hotel room, where he was under quarantine after testing positive for COVID-19.’Just as in other European countries and the EU, all together China policy will be in transformation in transition for some time,” Butikofer said. ‘We cannot return to the China policy of yesterday here, because the realities have changed.” Scholz’s visit also comes as Chinese investment in a container terminal at the Hamburg port has raised concerns in Washington and elsewhere that China is gaining a major grip on key infrastructure in an allied nation. Scholz has downplayed the significance of the deal and in a compromise, China’s COSCO was cleared to take a stake in the port below 25%, prohibiting it from blocking the company’s decisions. Despite the disputes, trade ties remain crucial. China was Germany’s biggest trading partner in 2021 for the sixth consecutive year, its biggest single source of imports and its No. 2 export destination after the United States.Scholz has pledged to use his trip to make the case for Chinese moderation and assistance in calming the situations with Ukraine and Taiwan.In the face of Chinese threats to annex Taiwan by military force, the self-governing island republic has drawn increasing support from Western politicians, even while their governments maintain only unofficial relations with Taipei in deference to Beijing. Butikofer said Germany’s governing coalition had agreed on a first-ever ‘clear expression of support for Taiwan’s democracy against China’s aggression,” as well as Taiwan’s ‘meaningful participation” in international organizations from which it is currently excluded at China’s insistence.Visiting along with Butikofer were parliamentarians Els Van Hoof of Belgium, Sjoerd Sjoerdsma of Holland and Mykola Kniazhytskyi of Ukraine. At a news conference, Taiwanese Foreign Minister Joseph Wu said the delegation’s visit ‘demonstrates the strength of the relations between Taiwan and the European Union and the bond that unites us with like-minded democracies across the globe.” Sjoerdsma said the visit had special resonance following last month’s twice-a-decade congress of China’s ruling Communist Party, at which Xi Jinping reiterated Beijing’s determination to ‘reunify” with Taiwan. The sides split amid civil war in 1949 and the vast majority of Taiwanese reject Beijing’s calls to accept Chinese rule. ‘We have a message to Beijing and I think the core message of our visit here is … that Taiwan is not to be isolated, but that contacts will only increase, that we will not be intimidated, that will be coming over more often, and that our relations and our friendships are not to be determined by others,’ Sjoerdsma said.